How to Transition Your Dog to New Food Without Rushing
By Dr. Hannah Godfrey, PhD Β· Β· Updated

New food, upset tummy, a pup who sniffs the bowl and walks away: most switches go wrong because they happen too fast. Here's how to transition dog food the way our nutrition team recommends: mix the new food into the old one over about seven days, then give your dog's gut a few more weeks to settle. The same plan works for our gently-cooked dog meals and for any other recipe.
Not sure which recipe to switch to yet? Take the meal quiz first. It matches your dog with meals and a daily portion, so the transition starts with the right food and the right amount.
How long should a dog food transition take?
A dog food transition should take about 7 days for most healthy adult dogs, and longer for dogs with sensitive stomachs. The American Kennel Club recommends a gradual switch over 5β7 days and warns that changing dog food abruptly can cause vomiting, diarrhea and decreased appetite.1 The AKC also notes that dogs with sensitive stomachs, food allergies or other gastrointestinal conditions may need a longer transition.1
At Tom&Sawyer, we treat seven days as the starting point, not the deadline. Some dogs need two weeks or more. Your dog sets the pace.
How to transition dog food: a 7-day schedule
Switching dog food works best when the new recipe replaces the old one in steps of about 25%. This is the schedule our nutrition team gives every new member of the pack:
Days | Old food | New food |
Days 1 & 2 | 75% | 25% |
Days 3 & 4 | 50% | 50% |
Days 5 & 6 | 25% | 75% |
Day 7+ | 0% | 100% |
If your dog has any trouble adjusting, stay at the current stage for a few more days before moving on. Once your dog is eating 100% of the new diet, it can take another few weeks for digestion to adjust completely.
Takeaway: move forward only when the stool from the current stage looks normal.
Why does changing dog food too fast upset the stomach?
Changing dog food too fast upsets the stomach because the digestive system and gut microbiome are tuned to the diet your dog already eats. Dogs break down food using enzymes, hormones and other physiological processes. The nutrients released fuel your dog with energy, and they also shape the microbiome in the digestive tract.
When the same diet is fed day in and day out, the digestive system and the microbiome become accustomed to it. A new food changes the composition and formulation of what arrives in the gut. Without a transition, that change can shock the system: it affects enzyme production and secretion and hormones, and can cause dysbiosis (an imbalance) of the microbiome.
Together, those effects can show up as:
- diarrhea or soft stool
- gas
- upset stomach or vomiting
- refusing the new food altogether
A slow transition lets the digestive system acclimatize and find a new routine.
How is transitioning a dog to fresh food different?
Transitioning a dog to fresh food follows the same 7-day schedule, but three things change: the food holds more water, portions are set by calories rather than cups, and the meals are stored frozen.
Fresh food is mostly water, so the bowl looks bigger
Our gently-cooked meals list a maximum moisture of 73β78% in their guaranteed analysis. That water is why a fresh meal looks generous. Don't shrink the portion because the bowl looks full: follow the feeding guide that comes with your dog's Meal Plan.
Mix by calories, not by cup
Each of our meals lists its calories per pack (for example, 473 kcal per pack for the Thai Coconut Chicken & Rice Recipe). When you mix old and new food, think in shares of your dog's daily calories, not in scoops. A peer-reviewed study of human grade dog foods also found that the standard equations for predicting energy underestimated the energy content of the foods tested,2 so weigh your dog every couple of weeks and adjust with your vet if needed. Our guide on how much to feed your dog or cat walks through the maths.
Thaw a day ahead
Move tomorrow's food from the freezer to the fridge overnight, portion it, and store any leftovers in the fridge.
What should you watch for while changing dog food?
While changing dog food, watch your dog's stool, appetite and energy every day, and treat them as your guide to the pace. Small changes in stool texture during the first week are common; changes that don't settle are the signal to slow down.
Signs the transition is on track
- Stool is formed and easy to pick up
- Your dog finishes meals with interest
- Energy and behaviour are normal
Signs to slow down
- Soft stool or extra gas at a new stage: go back to the last ratio that worked for two or three days
- Your dog picks around the new food: keep the share of new food where it is for a few more days
When to call your veterinarian
Call your vet if vomiting or diarrhea continues, if you see blood, or if your dog seems lethargic. Ongoing stomach upset after your dog is eating 100% of the new diet is also a reason to reach out for the best next steps. Our guide to diarrhea in dogs explains what to look for.
Tips that make switching dog food easier
Switching dog food goes more smoothly when everything else stays the same. These habits help:
- Keep fresh, clean water available all day. Water is an important factor for digestion and overall digestive health.
- Limit treats and table scraps. It may be RUFF, but fewer extras give the gut a simpler signal to adjust to.
- Keep meal times consistent. Same times, same place, same bowl.
- Be patient with sensitive pups. Dogs with a sensitive stomach or a gastrointestinal condition may need well over seven days.
Which Tom&Sawyer meal should you switch to?
The best Tom&Sawyer meal to switch to is the one that matches your dog's needs, and the meal quiz picks it for you. Every one of our recipes is made with 100% human grade ingredients, gently-cooked in an inspected human food facility, and formulated to meet AAFCO nutrient profiles.
That human grade standard matters for digestion. A peer-reviewed study of dog foods made with human grade ingredients found that, for the majority of essential amino acids, digestibilities were greater than 85%, with some greater than 90%.2 Our article on what dog food digestibility really means explains why that shows up in the yard.
If your dog has a history of tummy trouble, start with our meals for sensitive stomachs, such as the low fat Thai Coconut Chicken & Rice Recipe, and use the slower end of the schedule. You can also mix our food with what your dog already eats, with a smaller daily portion: a gentle way to start transitioning a dog to fresh food.
Ready to make the switch with Tom&Sawyer?
Making the switch with Tom&Sawyer starts with a few questions about your pup: age, weight, body condition and any sensitivities. Build your pup's Meal Plan and you'll get recommended meals, a daily portion and a transition guide, delivered on your schedule as one of Sawyer's Loyal Companions.
We'd love to hear how your doggo is enjoying their new, chef-inspired gently-cooked meals (photos are encouraged)!
Please consult your veterinarian before making changes to your pet's diet, especially if your pet has a medical condition.
Resources
- American Kennel Club. "How to Switch & Transition Dog Foods." AKC Staff. https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/nutrition/right-way-switch-dog-foods/
- Oba, P. M., Utterback, P. L., Parsons, C. M., & Swanson, K. S. (2020). True nutrient and amino acid digestibility of dog foods made with human-grade ingredients using the precision-fed cecectomized rooster assay. Translational Animal Science, 4(1), 442β451. https://doi.org/10.1093/tas/txz175
