40% off first order40% Off Your First Order — applied automatically at checkout

Log in
Tom&Sawyer
Shop
Meet the ExpertsBlog
Build a plan

Trick or Treat: Treats your Pets Should Avoid

By Dr. Hannah Godfrey, PhD · October 29, 2024

It’s spooky season! And this means that many of us will have some extra treats (for ourselves) lying around. But how can we safely include our fur family in all the fun?

Halloween candy is delicious, and Trick-or-Treating can be fun for the whole family – so here we break down some “treats” to beware of, and give pointers for safe Halloween dog and cat treats.

1. Chocolate

Why is chocolate bad for dogs and cats? Chocolate, especially dark chocolate , is very dangerous for our fur babies when consumed. Keep any chocolate-based treats out of reach from your pets. There are multiple components to chocolate that make it hazardous for our fur family. Caffeine is found in chocolate and, when consumed by dogs and cats, can cause rapid breathing, muscle tremors, and heart palpitations. Similar symptoms and more serious symptoms, including seizures and cardiac issues, can arise from the theobromine content of chocolate.

2. Xylitol

Sugarless candies (and essential oils, mints, and baked goods) might seem like a good treat idea for your pets, but beware! These candies use xylitol to sweeten them up – and xylitol is extremely toxic to dogs. Within 10 to 15 minutes after consumption, dogs can start to experience symptoms such as hypoglycemia and liver failure. Less information is available for our feline-friends though these should still be avoided in cats.

3. Halloween-Themed Cocktails (Alcohol)

Spooky-themed cocktails can really turn your Halloween party into a super fun Monster-Mash! However, your pets should not be part of this fun. Alcohol poisoning in cats and dogs results in lowered blood pressure, body temperature, and blood sugar levels. In fact cats can experience liver damage and brain damage in response to alcohol poisoning. Other signs can include confusion, clumsy and staggered movements, and vomiting. Any garnishes used for cocktails may also pose a risk.

4. Halloween Decorations

Many decorations used for Halloween can easily be snatched up and consumed by our pets. Try to use decorations that can’t be easily taken down by your pup or kitty, or keep them strategically out of reach. Certain decorations can cause obstructions in the gastrointestinal tract. In addition, your pets may have severe vomiting, may be dehydrated, and ultimately may require surgery (which can be pricey) if the items cannot be passed on their own.

5. Overeating

Coincidentally, Halloween wraps up Pet Obesity Month (October). So here is your reminder that treats should all be fed in moderation and as part of a complete and balanced diet. Treats should not exceed more than 10 % of your pets’ daily calorie intake . Too many treats can cause gastrointestinal upset , vomiting, stomach pains, diarrhea, pancreatitis , and i n the long-term can cause obesity and other serious health consequences.

Let’s keep the scares at the haunted houses and not our own homes! Stick to treats that your pet will love and can be fed as a complete and balanced diet.

For more information on toxic foods/items or what to do in an emergency , we have provided some resources below:

Pet Poison Helpline | 855-764-7661 | www.petpoisonhelpline.com | Available 24-hours (Canada, US, Caribbean)

Animal Poison Control Center | 888-426-4435 | www.aspca.org

US Food & Drug Administration (FDA ) | www.fda.gov

Chocolate Toxicity Calculator for Dogs (Includes other toxic foods) | www.vetcalculators.com

Your Veterinarian

What are the best Halloween dog and cat treats ? Usually treats that you would normally give your pet. Tom&Sawyer offers a variety of delicious recipes your dog or cat will love, and you can feed any of our gently cooked meals as a treat, topper , partial or full diet.

Article written by: Hannah Godfrey BSc H | MSc | Phd Student in Animal Nutrition

About the author

Dr. Hannah Godfrey, PhD

Animal Nutritionist · Lead Nutrition Scientist & Technical Advisor

Hannah leads the nutrition science behind every Tom&Sawyer recipe — a PhD animal nutritionist who turns peer-reviewed nutrition into meals portioned to each pet's real needs.

More from the journal

  • Can Dogs Eat Sweet Potatoes? The Powerful Superfood Your Dog Might Already LoveSweet potatoes show up in a lot of high-quality pet nutrition for good reason. Can dogs eat sweet potatoes? Yes, and we'd go further than that. Sweet potatoes are one of the most nutrient-dense, digestible, and well-tolerated whole-food ingredients you can put in a dog's bowl.
  • National Kitten Day: What Early Cat Meals Can Teach Us About Building Better Feeding HabitsNational Kitten Day on July 10 is one of those moments that invites a bigger conversation. It's not only about celebrating how small and determined kittens are. It's about what we choose to feed them from the very start, and what those early choices set in motion.
  • What We See in Summer Bowls: How Hydration Changes the Way Dogs and Cats Eat in JulyJuly is National Pet Hydration Awareness Month, and if you pay close attention to your pet's bowl during the warmer months, something shifts. Dogs get slower about finishing their meals. Cats grow even more selective than usual. These changes aren't random. They reflect how summer heat affects appetite and fluid balance in ways that go well beyond simply needing more water.
Tom&Sawyer
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
Get started
  • Shop
Why Tom&Sawyer?
  • Our Standards
  • Science & Research
  • Our Story
  • Giving Back
  • Meet the Experts
  • Reviews
Explore
  • Blog
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Find a Retailer
  • Account
Join the pack

Get access to the latest updates in pet health and wellness, exclusive offers, and more!

Tom&Sawyer
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
Get started
Why Tom&Sawyer?
  • Our Standards
  • Science & Research
  • Our Story
  • Giving Back
  • Meet the Experts
  • Reviews
Explore
  • Blog
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Find a Retailer
  • Account
Join the pack

Get access to the latest updates in pet health and wellness, exclusive offers, and more!

© 2026 All rights reserved.
Shipping & ReturnsTerms of SaleTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
Build my pet's plan