40% off first order40% Off Your First Order — applied automatically at checkout

Log in
Tom&Sawyer
Shop
Meet the ExpertsBlog
Build a plan

Gently-Cooked Pet Food 101: Everything You Need to Know

January 6, 2025 · Updated February 8, 2025

As pet owners, we all want the best for our furry friends, and a nutritious diet is key. Interest in fresh, gently-cooked pet food has grown, and for good reason.

The appealing flavours and textures of gently-cooked food make it a great choice for picky eaters. Plus, it’s been linked to several pet health benefits and can help with many health issues.

Gently-cooked food is prepared at the same minimum temperatures used to make our own food safer to eat. It involves cooking ingredients at low temperatures – just enough to kill harmful pathogens like E. coli and salmonella. This keeps the food safe while preserving its natural flavours and nutritional value.

What should I look for when choosing gently-cooked pet food?

Here are three major things that differentiate the options available:

● Complete & Balanced : If you’re feeding this food as all or part of a primary diet (more than 10% of your pet's daily intake), look for "Complete & Balanced," indicating the food meets the nutritional needs for your pet’s specific life stage (whether puppy, kitten, adult, or all life stages), otherwise it is not meant to be fed as a diet.

● Human-Grade : Look for “100% AAFCO Human Grade Dog/Cat Food” on the label. This means the food is made in a facility that meets human food standards. If you don’t see this exact claim, it’s not human-grade and is a lower-grade product.

● Cooking Style : Look for gently-cooked food that prioritizes cooking each ingredient separately. This shows that they understand the temperature's effect on digestibility and availability of each ingredient, plus the best taste and texture. There is also “sous vide" cooking, which sounds fancy but means that all ingredients are cooked in one plastic pouch at the higher temperature needed for meat, destroying nutrients in delicate vegetables.

Where do I find and how do I store this type of food?

In the freezer! Gently-cooked pet food is free from preservatives, so it stays fresh when frozen. Defrost the package under running water, and store leftovers in an airtight container inside your fridge for up to 4 days – just like your own leftovers.

Can I make gently-cooked food for my pet at home?

While it’s possible, here are three reasons it’s not recommended:

1) Ingredient Inconsistency: When buying ingredients from the grocery store, there can be nutrient differences between brands or availability, and what you may think is a minor change of an ingredient can have a major impact on nutritional levels.

2) Improper Cooking Methods: How you cook each ingredient matters. For example, if broccoli isn’t cooked enough, your pet may not be able to absorb all its nutrients. If you overcook or burn the chicken, valuable nutrients your pet needs from that ingredient are destroyed.

3) Not Complete & Balanced: Studies have shown that 90% of homemade pet food recipes are missing at least one essential nutrient leading to an unbalanced diet over time.

Now I’ve made the switch, how do I know it’s working?

Your pet is eagerly eating their new gently-cooked food and now you're eager to see all the benefits. One of the first things you may notice is a change in your pet’s poop – and poop can tell us a lot about our pet's health! You’ll likely start seeing smaller, firmer, and healthier-looking poops. But why does this happen?

According to new research at the University of Illinois, gently-cooked, human-grade pet food can alter the microbiome and was reported to have a higher digestibility of certain nutrients, such as protein, compared to other types of food like kibble. It makes your pet feel their best from the inside out. Benefits of a healthy microbiome and digestible pet foods can include:

● Better digestion

● Improved nutrient absorption

● Increased energy (the zoomies!)

● Stronger immune system

● Shiny skin and coat

Adding even a small portion of gently-cooked food to your pet’s bowl can make a noticeable difference in their health and well-being. Try it today and see for yourself.

Tom&Sawyer — Gently-Cooked Pet Food 101: Everything You Need to Know
Hannah Godfrey, Tom&Sawyer Animal Nutritionist

More from the journal

  • Can Dogs Eat Sweet Potatoes? The Powerful Superfood Your Dog Might Already LoveSweet potatoes show up in a lot of high-quality pet nutrition for good reason. Can dogs eat sweet potatoes? Yes, and we'd go further than that. Sweet potatoes are one of the most nutrient-dense, digestible, and well-tolerated whole-food ingredients you can put in a dog's bowl.
  • National Kitten Day: What Early Cat Meals Can Teach Us About Building Better Feeding HabitsNational Kitten Day on July 10 is one of those moments that invites a bigger conversation. It's not only about celebrating how small and determined kittens are. It's about what we choose to feed them from the very start, and what those early choices set in motion.
  • What We See in Summer Bowls: How Hydration Changes the Way Dogs and Cats Eat in JulyJuly is National Pet Hydration Awareness Month, and if you pay close attention to your pet's bowl during the warmer months, something shifts. Dogs get slower about finishing their meals. Cats grow even more selective than usual. These changes aren't random. They reflect how summer heat affects appetite and fluid balance in ways that go well beyond simply needing more water.
Tom&Sawyer
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
Get started
  • Shop
Why Tom&Sawyer?
  • Our Standards
  • Science & Research
  • Our Story
  • Giving Back
  • Meet the Experts
  • Reviews
Explore
  • Blog
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Account
Join the pack

Get access to the latest updates in pet health and wellness, exclusive offers, and more!

Tom&Sawyer
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
Get started
Why Tom&Sawyer?
  • Our Standards
  • Science & Research
  • Our Story
  • Giving Back
  • Meet the Experts
  • Reviews
Explore
  • Blog
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Account
Join the pack

Get access to the latest updates in pet health and wellness, exclusive offers, and more!

© 2026 All rights reserved.
Shipping & ReturnsTerms of SaleTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
Build my pet's plan